Editorial: Reasonable approach to Hasidic growth needed in Outremont

Outremont borough council is headed for yet another clash with its Hasidic communities over new zoning restrictions that are clearly aimed at them. The council, with the sole exception of councilor Mindy Pollack – who is Hasidic herself – has voted to bar new places of worship on largely commercial Bernard and Laurier. A referendum, if enough people sign a register, is expected on the issue later this year.

This move is a clear message to borough Hasidic communities that they can no longer develop the very institutions that define them – their prayer and devotion sites. They’re banned on Van Horne.

They are growing exponentially, with an average birth rate of about six children per family. The rate in Quebec is 1.74, below replacement level of 2.1. Outremont Jews, mostly Hasidim, constitute about 20 per cent of the borough’s 24,000 population.

Since the zoning restriction is clearly aimed at the only faith community that needs more houses of worship, it appears to contravene constitutional rights against discrimination based on religion.

The Hasidic association has hired constitutional lawyer Julius Grey, who has served notice he intends to launch a court challenge on this basis.

This bylaw was sparked when the Hasidic community rented an abandoned storefront on Bernard at the corner of Champagneur, across from the Outremont Theatre, where it was to open a synagogue. This was seen as a direct threat to restaurants, bars, and shops centered around Outremont Ave. – a frontal assault on what could be called the Little Champs Elysée of the intellectual and artistic élite that calls Outremont home. But it is not clear why using that storefront would prevent neighbouring shops, restaurants and bars from flourishing. 

In spite of this latest conflict, the 4,500 Hasidic community members who live in and around Outremont, including on adjoining streets and east of Park Ave., are thriving.

Anyone who spends time in the area can see it, in the huge number of children playing in its parks or riding bikes, in the schools and shops that cater to their needs, the way families dress up on Sabbath and head off to the area’s 15 little synagogues in their finery, in the calm way they walk to and from their homes, and how they respond to gestures of recognition and even friendship. In fact, only four of the synagogues are in Outremont. The others are on the streets of neighbouring Mile End.

It is a burgeoning community, with some families having ten or more children, and a brisk real estate market that reflects it. Much of the transition from an original few hundred has been relatively peaceful.

Yes, anti-Hasidic activists have protested virtually every time the community converts an empty storefront into a school or synagogue. But the end result has been to accommodate rather than to confront.

Some residents will remember that the old general store and light lunch counter called Victor’s on Bernard near Querbes in the 1950s was quietly converted to a ritual bath. Nobody complained. The Hasidic community is growing, and their need for the limited stock of real estate in the borough grows along with their increasing numbers.

Religious practice, study, and spirituality are essential to the life of these communities. Yes, it sometimes puts them at odds with secular residents who patronize the restaurants, bars, and shops.

Not all may understand, but the followers of various Hasidic sects, such as Belz, Satmar, Vishnitz, and Klausenberg, follow the teachings and traditions of individual revered rabbis and their dynasties, and so their followers require their own synagogues – hence the proliferation.

So what if a storefront on Bernard and Champagneur is not viable as a restaurant or shop, and a Hasidic community rents or buys? Why should the laws of economics not apply when there is a limited supply of non-residential property and a community is willing to invest resources to meet its needs? Who is inconvenienced?

Because they are not able to use vehicles on the Sabbath and the more serious holidays, community members, including children, seniors, and the infirm, need to have their synagogues within walking distance. It is therefore reasonable for them to seek accessible spaces.

Hasidic residents are happy where they live. Outremont council should take a conciliatory approach and seek to reasonably accommodate their needs rather than bludgeoning them with discriminatory restrictions.

In this struggle, which principles and practices will win out: freedom of expression, religion, association, and the reality of the real estate market, or restricting a community in full effervescence?

We urge a conciliatory approach, based not on restrictions, but consultation, cooperation and above all goodwill.

6 Comments on "Editorial: Reasonable approach to Hasidic growth needed in Outremont"

  1. Don Rosenbaum | June 23, 2016 at 7:16 am | Reply

    After reading “Unorthodox” – a contemporary memoir about growing up among the Hassids in Brooklyn – I believe they are a cult, indoctrinating the young, providing them with a limited and skewed world view, with the role of women as baby makers, to replace those killed by Hitler. It is difficult to muster up ‘goodwill’.

    • Cheskie Weiss | June 23, 2016 at 5:43 pm | Reply

      Don, Deborah Feldman obviously had personal vendettas to settle with her former community. Believing her stuff is similar to believing what the Nazi propaganda wrote about all Jews. Here’s a good read exposing the lies of Feldman http://deborah-feldman-exposed.blogspot.ca/

    • abigailhirsch47 | June 23, 2016 at 6:00 pm | Reply

      Don, you are basing your analysis on a book. It is just as prejudiced as those who live in Outremont and simply can’t stand the sight of Hasidic Jews as their neighbours. I say this from having attended Outremont town hall meetings where Hasidim and other residents also take the microphone.

    • Yitty Hirsch | June 23, 2016 at 7:49 pm | Reply

      Hi Don! As a local Hassidic woman, I invite you to visit the neighbourhood and engage its residents in conversation. Contrary to the negative stereotypes perpetuated by the media, the Hassidic women of Outremont are highly educated, multiingual and polished members of society. Many hold professional positions and others are successful entrepreneurs. Come on by and have a chat!

  2. Hi Don, I live in Outremont and am not Hassidic but have Hassidic friends thanks to Friends of Hutchison. We all work together to try to ensure respect and celebrate diversity. Check out the Facebook page and come and join us for our activities someday. And thank you Mr. Irwin Block for such an excellent article that is spot on.

  3. Leo Grinberg | June 24, 2016 at 12:38 am | Reply

    Leo Grin
    It’s about time that we should be able to live our life the way we want to .
    We don’t tell you how to live you’re lives so leave us alone

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.